> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://lower-case.ghost.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Disinformation Won on Prop One
- URL: https://lower-case.ghost.io/disinformation-won-on-prop-one/
- Published: 2026-11-07T14:11:28.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T03:13:23.000Z
- Description: A Post-Mortem on the Idaho Midterms
- Author: dotfuego
- Tags: Disinfo, Disinformation, Idaho, Local News, News, Elections, Data Centers, Tech, Surveillance

Alright so that didn't go as we'd hoped.

Proposition One failed; most of the local Progressive candidates lost; and Todd Achilles came up short in the race for the US Senate. In other words, the results looked exactly like the results from basically every other election in Idaho's recent history. 

Republicans won and, moreover, *they didn't even have to try*.

Many didn't even campaign.

Jim Risch and Brad Little refused to debate or even acknowledge their opponents. In the local races, I saw Progressive candidates spend months working hard and knocking on doors, and it just didn't seem to matter. It didn't move the needle. Despite sky-rocketing prices and everything getting demonstrably worse, people voted Republican anyway. I thought Todd Achilles ran a great campaign, but the final results looked nearly identical to the last Idaho Senate race. Ultimately, our best efforts weren't enough.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/6c/5e/6c5ea728-2dc3-45a6-82d9-e93c36848ecb/content/images/2026/11/image-3.png)

So what should we take from this? What lessons can be learned? Thankfully, I think there are key lessons, although many reflect systemic issues that will be difficult to overcome.

### **1) Disinformation Won on Prop One**

Nearly every Conservative I talked to about Proposition One said something that was wildly untrue. The most common thing I heard was that Prop One would allow elective abortion up to nine months (or even post-birth). It doesn't help that Donald Trump has [said the same thing](https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/10/trump-post-birth-abortion-attacks/680272/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io). This is, of course, not true, but what is truth in the modern information landscape?

As Mark Twain ([or possibly someone else?](https://style.mla.org/five-commonly-misattributed-quotations/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io)) once said, "*a lie can travel around the world and back again while the truth is lacing up its boots.*”And this is the problem with disinformation. Once it has spread, it's almost impossible to contain. Eventually the sheer volume of lies buries any attempt at telling the truth. 

This is, arguably, the foremost tactic in disinformation. It's called [Flooding the Zone](https://www.newsweek.com/steve-bannon-flood-zone-strategy-explained-trump-policy-blitz-2027482?ref=lower-case.ghost.io).

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/6c/5e/6c5ea728-2dc3-45a6-82d9-e93c36848ecb/content/images/2026/11/image-5.png)

From Newsweek at the link above

It's even worse when that disinformation is coming from a supposed "trusted" source like a church or an established group. Some of these, like the Idaho Family Policy Center, [drafted their own study](https://www.idahostatesman.com/news/northwest/idaho/article316860510.html?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) that contradicted the claim that [OBGYN's were leaving Idaho](https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/08/idaho-abortion-ban-obstetrics-doctors-leaving/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io). This created a situation with mutually exclusive and competing "truths." When this happens, people tend to give up on figuring it out and just go with the truth or narrative they like best.

Here's author Peter Pomerantsev explaining how this works in a now-paywalled [Vox article](https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/1/16/20991816/impeachment-trial-trump-bannon-misinformation?ref=lower-case.ghost.io):

> The goal, he told me, wasn’t to sell an ideology or a vision of the future; instead, it was to convince people that “**the truth is unknowable**” and that the only sensible choice is “**to follow a strong leader**.”

### 2) Bland Respectability Politics Are Not Enough

I have a feeling I'm going to be saying this a lot in the next couple of years.

So much so that we should probably condense it to a simple acronym. So let's take "bland respectability politics are not enough" and shorten it to... BRPNE (pronounced "burp-knee"). The gist of it is that the same-old politics of respectability and affordability are not enough to unseat incumbents.

This isn't to say that these issues aren't important, but we have to do more if we're going to get people's attention and get them to consider switching their vote. And in a state like Idaho (where [60% of the population is a registered Republican](https://voteidaho.gov/data-and-dashboards/voter-explorer/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io)), you need people to cross party lines. The way to do this is to mobilize on popular issues and show strength. People are tired of vacant and inauthentic politicians (just look at the [petition circulating](https://www.change.org/p/house-democrats-choose-a-new-speaker?recruiter=659139&recruited%5Fby%5Fid=00b2a780-1583-0130-a17b-3c764e046567&share%5Fid=mnrGDVqYzd&ref=lower-case.ghost.io) about Hakeem Jeffries right now), and running a generic campaign on a generic platform will make any candidate look bad.

The same thing can be said for AI-generated content. This looks inauthentic and low-effort. People do not want an inauthentic and low-effort politician representing them.

### 3) There's No Infrastructure to Support Progressive Candidates

The Democratic Party is practically non-existent in rural Idaho.

And I understand why this is the case - after all, why invest time and money in races that you're likely to lose? But if we don't do something and build some kind of infrastructure, then we will always lose. Progressive and Democratic candidates are running races with little to no support or campaign infrastructure.

Whereas the far-right has local infrastructure and volunteers and websites and a half-dozen "patriot" slopcasts funded by out-of-state groups like the [Citizens Alliance of America](https://bonnersferryherald.com/news/2026/oct/29/citizens-alliance-of-idaho-is-not-idaho-funded/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io). If any kind of Progressive is ever going to win, then we need to challenge these networks. That will take time and, perhaps more importantly, funding. We need billboards and media. *If they're going to flood the zone, then we have to try and flood it back.*

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/6c/5e/6c5ea728-2dc3-45a6-82d9-e93c36848ecb/content/images/2026/11/image-9.png)

Just look at the difference in funding in the Congressional Race

### 4) Young People Didn't Show Up

This is an age-old problem (no pun intended). 

Younger people showed up at [lower rates](https://voteidaho.gov/data-and-dashboards/voter-explorer/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) than almost any other demographic. On the one hand, this is understandable. It's nearly always been the case in the American electoral system. On the other, I didn't see most campaigns make an effort to reach the youth. And when I discussed this with a few candidates, I was told that young people don't vote and outreach wasn't worth the effort.

I don't agree with this. Maybe this is because I still remember the Obama years when the [youth vote dominated the election](https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2008/11/13/young-voters-in-the-2008-election/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io), but I see young people as an enormous and untapped segment in the Idaho electorate. And they might be even easier to reach, because they tend to feel like *no one is actually representing them*.

Note - this is exactly how Zohran Mamdani [won the race for New York Mayor](https://circle.tufts.edu/latest-research/young-voters-power-mamdani-victory-shape-key-2025-elections?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) in 2025.

From the Center for Information & Research on Civic Learning and Engagement:

> According to exit polls, **75% of youth voted for Mamdani**, compared to 19% for former New York governor Andrew Cuomo and 5% for Republican Curtis Sliwa. Mamdani won the three-way race with 50% of the overall vote; young people were his strongest supporters out of all age groups.

### 5) There Were a Few Bright Spots

But I don't want to be overly negative here. 

We saw a significant [leftward shift](https://idahocapitalsun.com/2026/11/04/amid-national-blue-wave-idaho-democrats-could-gain-a-handful-of-legislative-seats/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) across the state; we watched Ellie Gilbreath give Mike Simpson one of the [closest races of his career](https://ballotpedia.org/Idaho's%5F2nd%5FCongressional%5FDistrict%5Felection,%5F2026?ref=lower-case.ghost.io); and we [won on HJR4](https://ballotpedia.org/Idaho%5FHJR%5F4,%5FGrant%5FLegislature%5FExclusive%5FAuthority%5Fand%5FProhibit%5FCitizen-Initiated%5FMeasures%5Fon%5FMarijuana,%5FNarcotics,%5Fand%5FPsychoactive%5FSubstances%5FAmendment%5F%282026%29?ref=lower-case.ghost.io). That's right, we beat the House Joint Resolution specifically designed to limit ballot initiatives and restrict our ability to participate in State Democracy. I think we won because the vast majority of people saw this for what it was: an attack on liberty.

And maybe this suggests a strategy going forward. Maybe we should be picking smaller and more incremental battles and showing that Progressives will actually fight for liberty and freedom. And maybe we should do the same thing and take real stances on emerging issues like data centers and widespread surveillance. These are principled issues.

Opposition to them is also [incredibly popular](https://www.wired.com/story/the-results-are-in-voters-hate-data-centers/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io).

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/6c/5e/6c5ea728-2dc3-45a6-82d9-e93c36848ecb/content/images/2026/11/image-12.png)

Some, like Boise Mayor Lauren McLean, have already taken a strong stance on data centers

In fact, the anti-Flock signature campaign carried out by [DeFlock Idaho](https://deflockid.org/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) was one of the only things I saw both [left and right agree on](https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/sep/05/flock-cameras-political-backlash?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) in this electoral cycle. We should mobilize on this and show that we'll actually defend our communities and our rights. And we should do this right now (and I mean *right now*) because [data centers](https://boisedev.com/news/2026/11/06/mclean-proposes-emergency-moratorium-on-some-data-centers-in-boise/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io) are [already coming for Idaho](https://www.kivitv.com/twin-falls/proposed-data-center-near-declo-idaho-sparks-mixed-reactions-among-residents-in-rural-farming-town?ref=lower-case.ghost.io).

### Conclusion

I've said a lot, so let me summarize it: we need to stop doing the same-old things, we need to pick fights we can win, and we need to show Idahoans that we'll stand up for their lands and their rights when the Republican Establishment ([and Brad Little](https://commerce.idaho.gov/incentives/data-center-sales-tax-exemption/?ref=lower-case.ghost.io)) will not. If we do this, we can build a foundation for future success in this state.

Whereas if we keep doing the same things, we'll see the same results.

---

**lowercase** is a project in countering hate and disinformation.

If you'd like to read more and help us fight the processes of algorithmic hate, then please consider [sharing](https://lower-case.ghost.io/disinformation-won-on-prop-one/#share/) this post and [subscribing](#/portal/) to our blog and newsletter. Thanks for reading!